Historical reliability of the acts of the apostles wikipedia. The book of acts is the link between the gospels and the epistles. Flavius josephus the wars of the jews or history of. By todd bolen july 2010 the death of herod agrippa i is one of the few events that is reported by both the book of acts and josephus. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Who was the egyptian that led the revolt of the assassins.
In his autobiography phlaouiou iosepou bios, written a. Photo by nicholas hoult, jack the giant slayer titus flavius josephus 37 bc 100 ad was a firstcentury romanojewish scholar, historian and hagiographer, who was born in jerusalemthen part of roman judeato a father of priestly descent and a mother who claimed royal ancestry. Josephus relevant writings were composed no earlier than a. Josephus, who briefly described the three major groupings of the judaism of the timeessenes, pharisees and sadduceessaid the latter believed that the soul died with the body. By comparison, longer works, such of those of josephus, often mentioned a patron. Of this man nothing more is known than is here recorded. The disappearance of his body, to be sure, was far from proving his resurrection, but the production of his body would have effectively disproved it. The gospel of lukethe book of acts it is lukes writings, both the gospel and the book of acts, that have the most points of contact with josephus, particularly the antiquities. Josephus spent the rest of his life in or around rome as an advisor and historian to three emperors, vespasian, titus and. Main chapters of the book analyse the role of the high priesthood and upper priesthood and of the herodian dynasty in post70 judaean politics. Josephus writings and their relation to the new testament. In the latter portion of acts, luke recorded three rejections of the jews to pauls overtures of salvation. What josephus describes is much more similar in nature to that which elishas servant saw 2 kings 6.
Matthew says that john taught those baptized to bring forth fruit in keeping with repentance. Most of these can be found in colin hemers magisterial work, the book of acts in the setting of hellenistic history. Did luke cut and paste material from josephus into acts. Description of the book josephus the complete works. Josephus does not describe anyone seeing a visible and bodily return of jesus into the air or anywhere else. Chapter 15 the works of flavius josephus bible study tools. The extant manuscripts of the book antiquities of the jews, written by the firstcentury jewish historian flavius josephus around 9394 ad, contain two references to jesus of nazareth and one reference to john the baptist the first and most extensive reference to jesus in the antiquities, found in book 18, states that jesus was the messiah and a wise teacher who was. We will see later in the book of acts that in many cities where paul took the gospel, the jews started riots.
Dating the book of acts is very useful in determining if the author used josephus as a source. Recounted wellknown historical events separately or depended on common sources 2. And immediately the angel of the lord smote him, because he gave not god the glory. Josephuss discourse to the greeks concerning hades. Now as soon as albinus was come to the city of jerusalem, he used all his endeavors and care that the country might be kept in peace, and this by destroying many of the sicarii. I shall abbreviate lukeacts as l, and the collective histories of josephus as j. Josephuss descriptions of the layout of the temple complex, including the boundary signs restricting the movements of gentiles and the location where roman soldiers were stationed, help us picture the. The account says that they saw chariots and troops.
Like most new testament books, there are differences between the earliest. Josephus mentions three specific rebels, and acts of the apostles mentions the same three judas the galilean, theudas and the egyptian. It has been claimed that the author of acts used the writings of josephus specifically antiquities of the jews as a historical source. And the people gave a shout, saying, it is the voice of a god, and not of a man. It is lukes writings, both the gospel and the book of acts, that have the most points of contact with josephus, particularly the antiquities. In the complete works you will discover what the new testament writers knew about abraham, moses, samuel, david, and solomon and examine an indepth history of herod and his infamous family. His major books are history of the jewish war 7579, the antiquities of the jews 93, and against. As in the case of theudas, jesus followers are confused with the deceivers who were seen as a threat to rome. Also, this comes from the same book of josephus that luke is supposed to have. The historical accuracy of acts the bart ehrman blog. He gives many examples of the differences between the letters of paul and the book of acts. The majority of scholars reject both this claim and the claim that josephus borrowed from acts, arguing instead that luke and josephus drew on common traditions and historical sources. See chapter 5 paras 1 and 2 in antiquities book 20.
Commentary on the book of acts bible study lessons. So the hebrews went out of egypt, while the egyptians wept, and repented that they had treated them so hardly. Proof that gamaliel who trained the apostle paul existed. According to josephus, the jews recognized 22 books as the scriptures of the jewish bible. In plan and language the book is probably influenced by the writings of nicholas of damascus, which josephus had also used in the antiquities. Flavius josephus, jewish priest, scholar, and historian who wrote valuable works on the jewish revolt of 6670 and on earlier jewish history. Josephus says that john commanded the jews to exercise virtue, that is, righteousness toward one another and piety toward god. Josephus an eyewitness to christianity josephus was a historian who lived from 37 a. New testament parallels to the works of josephus page two. Josephus reversed their order for his own narrative reasons. Presents messianic jewish narrativecommentary on chapters 1218 of the acts. Josephus was himself betrayed by john, chose an ally named silas. It has been claimed that the author of acts used the writings of josephus. We see that around 100 ad josephus plainly states the contents of the old testament was written between the time of moses and the days of artaxerxes i king of persia from 465 to 424 bc.
Saul in the books of josephus and acts answering christianity. Most notable are the numerous references in luke to events and persons that are also discussed, and are explained more fully, by josephus. For when felix and drusilla visit paul in jail, paul discusses justice, selfcontrol, and coming judgement, at which felix is terrified for some unexplained reason. Josephus contribution to new testament backgrounds a.
Josephus dedicated jewish antiquities, life and against apion to epaphroditus. The quest for the historical paul biblical archaeology. Richard carrier, in his paper on luke and josephus explains that the egyptian was first mentioned by josephus in both jewish wars 75 ce and antiquities of the jews 93 ce. Theophilus was a common name that means friend of god, which has a strong resemblance to epaphroditus, a common name that means touched by aphrodite. They have know from the beginning, if they are willing to testify, that i lived according to the strictest sect of our religion, as a pharisee. Josephus writings and their relation to the new testament bible. Acts with book summary versebyverse bible commentary. Montefiore the object of this article is to point out similarities between some important events recorded in the canonical gospels and acts on the one hand, and a series of prodigies recorded by josephus in his jewish war on the other hand, and to suggest a possible connection between them. He was a member of the priestly aristocracy of the jews, and was taken hostage by the roman empire in the great jewish revolt of 6670 a. Complete and unabridged, new updated edition ancient greek hardcover unabridged, september 1, 1980.
Here are some of the details that luke gets right in acts that cannot be derived from josephus. The parallel is particularly evident in acts which looks back to the first book, much as josephus looked back to jewish antiquities, in life and against apion. In the book of acts paul is made out to be an heroic and idealised figure in the time of the early church, for someone who was portrayed to be quite a controversial person who was not one of the twelve apostles must have had some time to develop and prove themselves to come across as heroic or idealised person of the church. The time josephus describes is the latter 50s ce, which is consistent with the quoted acts incident. What, though, about the book of acts, lukes account of the history of the early church, which features paul as one of its chief protagonists. As to this intended work of josephus concerning the reasons of many of the jewish laws, and what philosophical or allegorical sense they would bear, the loss of which work is by some of the learned not much regretted, i am inclinable, in part, to fabriciuss opinion, ap. Another person mentioned in acts chapter 5 verse 37 is judas of galilee, the founding father of the zealots. Luke recorded three rejections by the jews to peter and the apostles associated with him to the message of repentance and proclamation of the kingdom.
Although josephus does not mention paul of tarsus, he does discuss the procurators felix and festus, about whom we read in the book of acts. The complete works of the famous jewish historian, translated by william whiston. Josephus mentions ananias, the high priest, who was mentioned in acts 23. Acts puts the two together in a way that makes more sense if this account in josephus is understood, especially considering josephus portrayal of felix as notoriously cruel to the jews. Josephus and the old testament scriptures of the jewish. Why wouldnt josephusepaphraditus want the author of acts.
Details in josephuss account, however, indicate that the episode occurred in the city amphitheater next door to the temple where the emperor was worshipped. Illuminate your understanding of the new testament. Its subject and intention is nicely summarised by the words of the lord in chapter 1. Bruce, the book of acts,the new international commentary on the new testament rev. Bible our library history the works of flavius josephus antiquities of the jews book 2 chapter 15. Josephus recorded jewish history, with special emphasis on the first century. But ye will receive power, the holy spirit having come upon you, and ye shall be my witnesses both in jerusalem and in all judaea and samaria and to the end of the earth.
Presents messianic jewish narrativecommentary on chapters 111 of the acts of the apostles while filling in the broader picture with additional information from jewish sources, roman history, the writings of josephus, and early christian writings. Josephus described theudas as a selfproclaimed prophet who deluded the majority of the masses four hundred men according to acts with his promise to divide the jordan river upon command so that the people could cross with ease, thus repeating the miracle performed by. For a historically reliable account of what paul said and did, can we rely on lukes narrative. Josephus biographydefense, the antiquities of the jews, the wars of the jews, and against apion. The works of flavius josephus is in the public domain and may be freely used and distributed.
Encounter the world and traditions that jesus knew. For the most part, those who believe that acts was written after a. This is the first time paul was identified in the book of acts as being a member of the pharisaic sect. The works of josephus as translated by william whiston in the 1700s. The complete works of flavius josephus legendary jewish historian and his chronicle of ancient history by translation by william whiston oct 15, 2008 4. In particular, the works of josephus, the firstcentury jewish historian. An excellent place to start is steve masons josephus and the new testament, which discusses more fully the parallels and provides many original observations and analyses. Flavius josephus, antiquities of the jews, book 19. The gospel of luke the book of acts it is lukes writings, both the gospel and the book of acts, that have the most points of contact with josephus, particularly the antiquities. Josephus, lukeacts, and politics in rome and judaea by 100 ce in. Actus apostolorum, often referred to simply as acts, or formally the book of acts, is the fifth book of the new testament. Supposing this was true, then this would undermine luke as a historian.
The historical reliability of the acts of the apostles, the principal historical source for the. Josephus, and matthew and mark, refer to john as the baptist. What does josephus tell us about john the baptizer. Josephuss descriptions of the layout of the temple complex, including the boundary signs restricting the movements of gentiles and the location where roman soldiers were stationed, help us picture the events chronicled in acts 21. The purpose of the book of acts is governed by the jews response to peter and paul. Flavius josephus jewish priest, scholar, and historian. Josephus writes in his autobiography, life, that while governor of galilee about 61. Become a member of biblical archaeology society now and get more than half off the regular price of the allaccess pass. There has long been the observation that lukeacts contains numerous parallels with the works of josephus, generating three different theories to account for this. Some sceptics and scholars claim that biblical author luke had read a book called antiquities by jewish historian josephus, and borrowed his material, in order to invent fake scenes in the book of acts, only to get the real details wrong. The kindle edition also features some defenses of josephus by whiston. And upon a set day herod, arrayed in royal apparel, sat upon his throne, and made an oration unto them. To some of the jews the destruction of herods army seemed to be divine vengeance, and certainly a just vengeance, for his treatment of john, surnamed the baptist. Luke informs us that this famine occurred during the reign of claudius caesar.
617 92 64 701 1001 1376 1554 1287 369 1482 371 1530 374 938 1309 275 952 1120 1251 688 55 301 399 360 34 612 110 615 416 1215 302 487